PHOTOS AND VIDEOS
REVIEWS Write a Review
My husband and I usually eat at Pizzalley's if we've got a hankerin' for pizza on St. George street, but one night they were absolutely slammed so we decided to give Pizza Time a try as we had never tried it since it opened.
The first downside to this restaurant is the fact that they don't take checks (not even local) or credit cards. They do, however, ""conveniently"" have an ATM right next to their cash register, which will of course charge you a fee to use it. (Beware of charges from your bank at the end of the month, too; those will sneak up on you.)
The food was ""alright"" but not very good. The pizza-by-the-slice was not very fresh, and while the little rolls looked really tasty they lacked any flavor. (Perhaps add a little garlic or parmesan flavoring to them? They looked but didn't taste buttery. Disappointing!) Later on in the evening the pizza wasn't sitting very well in my stomach. (Such is the risk you take when you order pizza by-the-slice.)
The staff were friendly though... but I think we'll stick to Pizzalley's.
When I worked downtown, Pizzalley's was the place to go for food. They offer a large assortment of not just pizzas, but sandwiches and their fries were good too. :)
If you go to Pizzalley's, I also recommend trying out the breadsticks. Those could be a meal in themselves! The tortellini is pretty good too.
If you're in the mood for casual dining with friends or family, you can hit the pizza parlor in the front half; if you're looking for a more romantic dinner, they also have the ""Chianti Room"" in the back with a great setting and full service. Both halves of the restaurant offer good service and excellent food.
We've only experienced the Chianti Room once, but the Margherita Pizza was great; a little pricey but worth it, very fresh and flavorful.
This is one of the best restaurants in the downtown area, and for sure one that the locals all know and love. :)
- Extra Phones
Primary Phone: 904-825-2177
Primary Phone: 904-825-2627
- Regular Hours
Mon - Sun:
- Pizza, Caterers, Fast Food Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Restaurants, Seafood Restaurants
- Payment Options
- Price Range
- Spanish Quarter
Pizza Time Of St Augustine Inc
- Other Information
Cuisines: Caterers, Fast Food, Italian, European, Seafood, Continental, Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Alcohol: Beer, Full Bar, Wine
Bike Parking: Yes
Takes Reservations: No
Outdoor Seating: Yes