My family loves New York Pizziaria for the stone cooked pizza, great atmosphere, and friendly service.

great pizza but it is kind of greasy

other than that this is the place to go

it sounds to me like the bad review was written by a competitor and the glowing review was written by someone with a vested interest in the business. Neither review is correct. The place isn't the worst ever, but they are not a gift from the pizza gods either. Pickerington doesn't have great pizza selection so until adriaticos moves a location in this is the best we have but the others we have are donatos, pizza hut, pizza cottage, domino's, etc you get the idea.

The pizzeria new york in pickerington ,ohio is very good at there job. Everytime i have been in there i have had nothing but great food and service. All the employes is very respect full. i have never known the pizza shop to have ever close at 6:00 or 6:45pm because i am in there at least every two days. So i dont think that you should bad mouth this nice establishment without really trying to give it a chance.



pny's #1 fan

I drove an hour to get what was supposed to be the best pizza in town and they were closed at 6pm. Two weeks later, I called on a Sunday at 5:30pm to specifically ask what time they closed and was told 8:00pm. I once again drove an hour and the door was open, but the staff told me they were sorry, it was slow so they closed at 6:45pm. I have tried to make contact with the owner and he has not returned any of my calls. Management terrible, service terrible, ownerterrible. I will be filing with the Better Business Bureau. STAY AWAY FROM THIS ONE!

Great place toeat. The best pizza

ny style pizza?????the pizza we ordered had paper thin crust so thin there was only sauce and cheese in the middle of the pie when we cut it, also we had pineapple on the pizzawhich came in the form of chunks, just like it was taken out of then can and dumped on the pie. I was very disappointed in the quality but as far as the server,she was a very nice and courteous lady (blonde) and think she did a great job in terms of service.Overall good people, the pizza ... well....

Pizzeria New York has the best NY style pizza around! We found out about PNY through some friends, and since then have been loyal patrons. Overall, their delivery service has been very good, though one time they quoted us 45 minutes for delivery, and it was almost TWO HOURS before the pizza arrived. And to boot, the pizza was cold. When I called, all I got was "we're so sorry." That's it! We love the pizza, but I don't think this would be a fair review if this bad experience wasn't mentioned. But overall, we have a good experience with them every time which keeps us coming back!

I love this place. Order once if not twice every week. We lvoe it. I have waited 3 years of living in Ohio to find a place with good NY style pizza. FOUND IT!

I sort of stumbled on it, as I live in Westerville, but have work contacts in the area. Being an east coaster myself, I was definately impressed with the quality and taste of the pizza. Definately like pizza by the slice option too. Check it out, you won't be disappointed. Just build one near me and I would be very happy. - Lisa