We apologize for the inconvenience

The people search feature on Superpages.com is temporarily unavailable. You can still search for people on yellowpages.com since Yellow Pages and Superpages are part of one company.

You will be automatically re-directed to People Search on yellowpages.com in .

El Maguey Mexican Restaurant

Add to Favorites
Write a Review!
Mexican Restaurants, Latin American Restaurants, Restaurants

2737 Highway K, O Fallon, MO 63368


Today: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

REVIEWS write reviewWrite a Review


  • 5
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1
4 Reviews
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!



Provided by Citysearch

I have traveled extensively throughout the U.S. and half a dozen times to Mexico. El Maguey/O'fallon is the best hands down. The meat quality is consistantly good, tender beef tips (chimichanga) , skirt steak (carne asada tacos & fajitas). The salsa, if you like smooth, is spicy and delicious, the white cheese sauce is superior to any yellow cheese elsewhere with a nice kick, smooth quacamole to die for (no raw tomatoes or onions thankfully) and my dad loves the chile rellanos here. Equally important are the perfectly balanced margharitas that go down smooth, no acid burn or excessive lime taste. Don't forget, all El Maguey's are not created equal, O'fallon O'fallon O'fallon.

Was this Review helpful to you?0


Provided by Citysearch
I could eat here every week (maybe twice)!

I was introduced to El Maguey by my girlfriend about a year and a half ago and absolutely love it. We've eaten at numerous locations, and other than a few sub-par meals here and there the food is absolutely awesome. My personal favorite is the Chicken Quesadilla Fajita - the creamy cheese is delicious and the vegetables are cooked exactly as I like them. The chicken is also seasoned very well.

I'm also a huge fan of their chips and salsa. For those looking for a ""chunky"" salsa it may not be for you, but I prefer the thinner varieties and to me it has just the right amount of heat to it.

I suppose it would be nice if the rice had a little more ""kick"" but I do think it's quite good as-is.

Another reviewer's comment about the seating at the O'Fallon, MO location is true; we've always been fortunate to be seated at a booth but we dread getting stuck at one of the tables in the middle of the dining room, and the ones at the front are very close to the doors and the checkout counter. The smoking section is completely separate from the non-smoking section though, which is a huge added bonus. The restaurant is always packed with a wide range of diners, from couples like my girlfriend and me to families with young children.

The service is generally very good, although we have found the St. Charles location to be a little friendlier (that's not to say the O'Fallon servers are unfriendly or rude, but there is a difference). The food is ready amazingly fast, which is good as I tend to stuff myself with chips and salsa until it arrives.

I'm not a huge expert on Mexican food, and I have a fairly limited pallet for Mexican foods that I like, but El Maguey has made me try new things which, to me, says a lot about the quality of food they serve.

Was this Review helpful to you?0


Provided by Citysearch
Not my idea of Mexican flavor

So many people like El Maguey, but we find it flat, with no real flavor kick like true Mexican food has. This is the McDonalds of Mexican cooking, and if you like bland, you'll like this

Was this Review helpful to you?0


Provided by Citysearch
Great food, great value

Love the burritos and chimichangas at El Maguey. Service is usually very good here. Chips as salsa not as good as Chevy's in my opinion, but the entree's are better.

This location on Highway K does not offer much in the way of private seating. If you get seated near the entrance on a cold day, prepare for a freezing draft whenever people come in.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Regular Hours
Mon - Thu:
Mexican Restaurants, Latin American Restaurants, Restaurants, Take Out Restaurants
Payment Options
Price Range
Other Information

Good For Groups: Yes

Good for Kids: Yes

Attire: Casual

Take Out: Yes

Cuisines: Mexican, Take Out, Latin American

Takes Reservations: No

Outdoor Seating: No

Price Range : Below Average

Suggest an Edit
Data provided by one or more of the following: DexYP, Data Axle, Yext.