We apologize for the inconvenience

The people search feature on Superpages.com is temporarily unavailable. You can still search for people on yellowpages.com since Yellow Pages and Superpages are part of one company.

You will be automatically re-directed to People Search on yellowpages.com in .

Please note our privacy policy has changed. To view the policy, please go to https://corporate.thryv.com/privacy/click here

Anthony's Italian Restaurant

Add to Favorites
(10)
Write a Review!
Italian Restaurants, Caterers, Pizza

8809 Mitchell Blvd, New Port Richey, FL 34655

727-372-1663

CLOSED NOW: 
Today: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

REVIEWS write reviewWrite a Review

REVIEW SUMMARY

  • 5
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1
4
10 Reviews
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!

RGibbs

12/28/09

Provided by Citysearch
You've got to be kidding?!

My wife and I ate here yesterday for the first (and last) time. We live right around the corner so we thought we would try it out. We ordered a carafe of Cab, only to receive a container of spoiled wine. Smelled like sour vinegar, I couldn't believe they even brought it out. The waitress, Bobbie Joe, was nice, but not really that helpful. The french onion soup was nice, too bad I won't be back. The fried mushrooms were good as well. The pizza however, was completely inedible. It was lukewarm, the mozzarella was cold and rubbery, and there was more crust (which was more than two inches thick) than there were toppings. We did take a bite....yuck! No manager came to us, although they did take it off the bill...I wouldn't have paid for it anyway! What a disappointment. You would figure in this economy that an establishment would be more sensitive to their patrons. We ended up going to Rossi's for pizza, which as usual, was good...

Was this Review helpful to you?0
foodcritic8809

11/07/07

Provided by Citysearch
Best Pizza in town and best food for the price.

Our experiences at Anthonys have been the most pleasurable of our adult lives. They have live entertainment, great food, fast friendly service, all in a very clean enviroment. We have had everything from New York style pizza to gormet Italian dishes, such as Zupppa De Pesche, chicken Marsala, and veal Franchaise. There is something for everyone on the menu and everyday they have a special, such as senior day, kids night, or dinner specials. You can tell the owners, and managers work hard to keep the place running smooth, you can see the owners helping out in the dinning room and kitchen when they need it. Most of the staff is from up north so they have the restaurant decorated with pictures of all the sights of the city, it is a cozy little place that reminds me of home. We will return many times and tell as many people that we can about this little slice of New York here in Florida.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
jcarl99818

04/26/07

Provided by Citysearch
Favorite Italian Spot

We have a pretty good variety of Italian Restaurants to choose from in our neighborhood and Anthony gets my vote for the best. We have eaten here about 9 times in the last 2 weeks and the food and service has been great! The garlic bread is wonderful. The bread is light and airy with just the right amount of seasoning. My favorite menu item is the Hot Italian Combo sandwich. The pizza is also very good. We like the crispy crust when we order the pie well done.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
connieinga

10/02/06

Provided by Citysearch
great food

i've been to anthony's many times. i've always enjoyed the food. they do get busy on the weekends, as does any good restaurant. you shouldn't hold a wait against any good restaurant. that should give you an idea on how good the pizza and food really is. i think anyone who would have anything bad to say about this place just does not have any patience. i can see them in the long lines at the grocery store... huffing and puffing and griping because there's only one lane open!! you should just stay home and order domino's. those who love good pizza will know that the pizza is well worth the wait. also, this is a family business. it's good to see the whole family involved in running the place. so what if they 'run their mouths' !! they are good people and deserve the support of the locals. i moved to the middle of nowhere. the only pizza i have the choice of getting is domino's. i miss anthony's food. i would love to have a slice of that awesome pizza... and couldn't care less to hear the 'stories' of the family... good for them!! i think that reviewer is probably a type A personality. i would recommend anthony's to anyone.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
M
maxgracedad

09/28/06

review count1photo count0
Good quality for the price

Great pie, garlic rolls and those little powdered sugar covered dough balls.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
beth4455

06/29/06

Provided by Citysearch
Best food in Florida

One question for you? why was Anthony's voted number one in the county? If you say its so bad.

I do not agree with any of your comments at all. I am from NY orignally and I've been to restaurants from Brooklyn to Manhattan. Their pizza is out of this world and definetly New York style. The atmosphere is also great i feel like im back on Mulberry St. I think the service is good and I always feel welcome. I dont know what your saying about the owners because they are very pleasant and are always there to make sure everythings going right. The other employee's seem like they have fun and love working there. There might be a wait sometime but they get very busy on the weekends and I can understand why. I am always in that restaurant and have never had a bad experience.

P.S. I think the people that have complained either own a restaurant or have family that have a restaurant that are in competition with Anthony's. --SOUR GRAPES--.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
demick

05/11/06

Provided by Citysearch
User review by demick

I agree I called for a price on a pizza and the girl forgot I was on the phone so I hung up after waiting 4minutes. I also attended a communion recently at this location and the service was terrible. The layout of the tables was a disaster and the waitress are not that bright.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
R
ruthie5041

03/19/06

review count1photo count0
A local favorite of mine - Great food and great people!

The best Pizza in town!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
ab22

03/07/06

Provided by Citysearch
Answer for you...

""One question for you?...


**One answer for you... because they paid for the advertisement.
I look at Tampa bays best for new idea's on where to go not for facts. Any day of the week you can pay to get into a mag or advertisement and then be seen on the 6 o'clock news in dirty kitchen segment. I say it's bad... and believe me the service is bad. Because that has been my experience over and over and over again.**

""I do not agree with any of your comments at all...

**Pizza is great, service is terrible. Believe me if they would just focus on customer service and the actual serving of food I would have no complaint.**

""The atmosphere is also great i feel like im back on Mulberry St. I think the service is good and I always feel welcome. I dont know what your saying about the owners because they are very pleasant and are always there to make sure everythings going right. The other employee's seem like they have fun and love working there. There might be a wait sometime but they get very busy on the weekends and I can understand why. I am always in that restaurant and have never had a bad experience.""

**That's great, I am happy for you and your prescription of Prozac.
That being said, they still need to clean up their act. I shouldn't know the stories that I do about he owner and her family by merely sitting there and waiting for a pizza and listening to them run their mouths

""P.S. I think the people that have complained either own a restaurant or have family that have a restaurant t. SOUR GRAPES

**Only 3 Italian restaurants in Trinity, don't own any of them. Once again for the ""special kids"" with helmets on out there... Food is great, service terrible, take it to go. Hopefully they'll clean up their act**

Was this Review helpful to you?0
DETAILS
Extra Phones

Phone: 727-376-2748

Fax: 727-376-2748

Hours
Regular Hours
Mon - Fri:
Sat - Sun:
Categories
Italian Restaurants, Caterers, Pizza, Restaurants
Payment Options
Price Range
$$
Location
Mitchell Crossing
Other Information

Parking: Lot, Private

Wi-Fi: Free

Bike Parking: Yes

Attire: Casual

Cuisines: Caterers, Italian, European, Continental, Pizza

Alcohol: Beer, Wine

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: Yes

Price Range : Average

Suggest an Edit
Data provided by one or more of the following: DexYP, Data Axle, Yext.