- Calamari$15.00Crispy fried until golden brown served with spicy marinara and lemon wedges
- Pretzel Sticks$12.00Four with Guinness whole grain mustard and warm cheese dipping sauce
- Crab Cakes$14.00Jumbo lump crab cakes with roasted corn salsa & arugula
- Lobster Sliders$18.00Fresh lobster in a spicy aïoli topped with arugula & avocado on potato sliders
- Baked Clams$12.00Fresh clams: chopped & stuffed, baked with butter & hint of white wine
- Mac'n'cheese Bites$10.00Homemade, fried golden, served with warm cheese sauce
- Queso Dip$10.00Made fresh, served with tortilla chips
- Sampler Platter$14.00Chicken fingers, baked clams, mozzarella sticks
- Buffalo Wings$12.00Eight jumbo buffalo wings
- Hummus$12.00Freshly made, served with pita points, tzatziki, carrots & celery
- Crispy Shrimp$14.00Battered in a Red Hook Ale, served with cocktail & tartar sauce
- Schafer's Steam Pot$18.00Choice of Sauce: Marinara or White Wine Garlic Butter. Choose: mussels or littleneck clams or combination
- Schafer's Seafood Tower$55.00Jumbo shrimp, oysters, clams & 1/2 lb. of snow crab. Add whole steamed lobster. Market
- Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail$15.00
- Snow Crab Legs$16.001 lb. chilled or warm with melted butter
- Fresh Blue Point OystersHalf Dozen: $12.00Dozen: $24.00
- Littleneck ClamsHalf Dozen: $6.00Dozen: $12.00
- Add Protein to Any Salad: Chicken $4 | Shrimp $6 | Salmon $7 | Ahi Tuna $8
- Long Island Clam Chowder$8.00Fresh clams, herbs, potatoes, corn & cream
- French Onion Soup$8.00Baked with mozzarella cheese & topped with house croûtons
- Beet & Goat Cheese$14.00Fresh spring mix, beets, goat cheese in Cabernet vinaigrette
- Schafer's House$10.00Fresh spring mix, carrot, tomato, cucumber in Cabernet vinaigrette
- Spring$14.00Romaine, sunflower seeds, pineapple, candied pecans, sweet potato curls, mozzarella in champagne vinaigrette
- Strawberry Field$13.00Greens, sliced almonds, strawberries, feta, avocado, berry vinaigrette
- Classic Caesar$12.00Romaine, house made croûtons & fresh shaved Parmesan
- BLT Cobb$14.00Romaine, feta, avocado, bacon, corn, tomato in house balsamic vinaigrette
- Catch of the DayChoice of preparation: broiled, blackened or sautéed with white wine & garlic. Served with roasted red potatoes & seasonal vegetable
- Schafer's Clam Bake$28.00P.E.I. mussels, clams, shrimp, snow crab, corn on the cob, potatoes & Andouille sausage in a white wine sauce
- Seafood Linguini$26.00Jumbo shrimp & lump crab in a tomato basil sauce
- Lobster Mac'n'cheese$23.00Lobster, penne & savory cheese blend
- Lobster Ravioli$24.00Lobster & baby spinach in roasted tomato sauce
- Lobster Roll$20.00Chopped shrimp & lobster meat with lemon aïoli & fries
- Sautéed Scallops$24.00Served over couscous with sautéed spinach
- Cedar Plank Salmon$24.00Roasted on cedar plank, served with rosemary roasted red potatoes, zucchini and yellow squash
- Coconut Shrimp$15.00Served with Thai sweet chili sauce and fries
- Classic Fish & Chips$16.00With tartar and lemon horseradish aïoli
- Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna$18.00Seared, topped with ginger dressing, served with bok choy
- Blackened Swordfish$27.00With pineapple chutney & side of couscous
- Steamed Whole LobsterWith baked potato & seasonal vegetable
- Schafer Burger$16.001/2 lb Angus beef, lettuce, tomato, bacon, cheese & sautéed onion served with fries
- Salmon Club$16.00Grilled Salmon, bacon, lettuce, avocado, basil aïoli on whole grain served with fries
- French Onion Chicken Sandwich$15.00Grilled chicken, mozzarella & sautéed onions with fries
- California Veggie Burger$14.00Lettuce, tomato, avocado, chipotle mayo & fries
- Steak Sandwich$16.00Sliced skirt steak, sautéed onions & peppers, mozzarella on a toasted roll with fries
- Caprese Flatbread$10.00Vine ripened tomatoes, basil & fresh mozzarella
- Spinach & Artichoke Flatbread$12.00Spinach, artichoke, mozzarella, Parmesan & creamy garlic sauce
- Barbecue Chicken Flatbread$12.00Barbecue chicken, red onion, bacon
- Fish Tacos$14.00Beer battered cod, avocado, cabbage, spicy aïoli, mango-black bean salsa with fries
- Buffalo Chicken Tacos$14.00Pulled chicken in buffalo, blend of shredded cheeses on flour tortillas served with fries
- Tuna Tacos$16.00Seared Tuna steak, avocado, Asian slaw, spicy aïoli on flour tortillas served with fries
- Herbed Grilled Chicken$18.00Served with a honey cream sauce, roasted red potatoes & seasonal vegetable
- Marinated Skirt Steak$22.00Grilled to your liking with chimichurri, roasted red potatoes & seasonal vegetable
- 12 Oz NY Strip Steak$24.00Grilled to your liking, house demi-glaze, crispy onion strings, roasted red potatoes, seasonal vegetable
- The MuleAbsolut Lime Vodka, ginger beer, lime juice, lime wedge
- Coconut Mint CollinsMalibu, mint leaves, soda, lime juice, lime wedge
- FloradoraPlymouth gin, lime juice, raspberry, ginger ale
- PalomaAltos tequila, grapefruit, club soda, lime wedge
- Harbor ParadiseMalibu, Absolut Lime Vodka, cranberry & pineapple juice
- Malibu Blue HawaiianMalibu, Blue Curacao, pineapple juice