- Supreme Bakery offers Special Occasion Cakes for Special Occasions. Listed below are cake sizes and prices. If you would like to order a cake you can do so by calling Supreme Bakery at (973) 736-1732 or you can email your information to orders@supremebakery.com
- 7"Butter Cream: $23.00Other Icing: $24.50Serves 3-6
- 8"Butter Cream: $32.00Other Icing: $33.50Serves 6-10
- 10"Butter Cream: $44.00Other Icing: $46.00Serves 10-15
- 12"Butter Cream: $63.50Other Icing: $68.00Serves 15-20
- 1/4 SheetButter Cream: $41.00Other Icing: $42.50Serves 10-15
- 1/2 SheetButter Cream: $70.00Other Icing: $72.50Serves 20-30
- 1/2 Sheet 3 LayerButter Cream: $92.00Other Icing: $95.00Serves 30-50
- Full SheetButter Cream: $120.00Other Icing: $125.00Serves 50-70
- Full Sheet 3 LayerButter Cream: $178.00Other Icing: $180.00Serves 75-100
- 7" Ice CreamOther Icing: $32.00Serves 6-10
- 8" Ice CreamOther Icing: $39.00Serves 10-15
- 10" Ice CreamOther Icing: $55.00Serves 15-20
- 1/4 Sheet Ice CreamOther Icing: $60.00Serves 15-20
- 1/2 Sheet Ice CreamOther Icing: $110.00Serves 25-35
- Full Sheet Ice CreamOther Icing: $185.00Serves 50-70
- Types of IcingButter Cream, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Fudge, Mocha Iced, Chocolate Mousse, and Cream Cheese
- Types of CakeYellow, Chocolate, Carrot, Red Velvet, and Marble. (Other than yellow cake is other icing price)
- Types of FillingsLemon, Strawberry, Pineapple, Peach, Cherry, Cannoli Cheese, Mocha B/C, Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Custard, Chocolate Fudge, Chocolate Mousse, and Cream Cheese
- Fresh Banana Extra Charges7" & 8" - add $0.75, 10" & 1/4 sheet - add $1, 12" & 1/2 sheet - add $1.5, Full sheet - add $2
- Fresh Strawberry Extra Charges7" & 8" - add $2, 10" & 1/4 sheet - add $4, 12" & 1/2 sheet - add $6, Full sheet - add $9
- Special Kit Decoration$10.00We have a selection of cake kits to put on your special cake. Some kits are bridal themed, baby shower, children's characters and themes, and more
- Computerized Portrait on Cake$10.00Bring in your picture to be scanned onto your special occasion cake. Supreme Bakery uses quality edible paper
- Brand New Cupcake Cake$1.85We now offer cupcake cakes. The minimum is 12 cupcakes. The other sizes are 16, 20, 24, & 30.
- "Our Classic" Strawberry Shortcake$18.50Yellow cake, pure whipped cream icing, sweet strawberry filling, topped with slices of fresh strawberries
- Cannoli Layer Cake$18.95Yellow cake, pure whipped cream topping, rich cannoli filling, topped with 3 mini cannoli treats
- Black Forest Cake$18.95Chocolate cake, cherry filling, pure whipped cream topping, topped with a cherry and chocolate cake crumbs
- Victory Cake$17.00A simple chocolate cake, pure whipped cream topping and filling
- Brown Derby Cake$19.25Chocolate cake, fresh fruit filling and whipped cream, topped with pure whipped cream and chocolate cake crumbs
- Tiramisu Layer Cake$18.95Marscapone cheese topped sponge layers soaked with espresso
- Lemon Layer Cake$18.50Yellow cake, lemon filling, butter cream icing, and fresh coconut.
- Mocha Yellow Layer Cake$18.95Mocha Icing (which is a mix of chocolate fudge and butter cream icing), mocha filling, and yellow cake. Also available with chocolate cake for
- Shadow Layer Cake$18.95Two layers of yellow cake, one layer of chocolate cake, mocha filling, and butter cream and chocolate swirl topping
- Pineapple Layer Cake$18.50Butter cream icing, yellow cake, and sweet pineapple filling
- Maple Walnut Layer$18.95Sweet maple taste added to our flavorful butter cream icing, maple butter cream filling, yellow cake, topped with fresh walnuts
- Cherry Layer Cake$18.50Yellow cake, butter cream icing, and cherry filling
- Strawberry Layer Cake$18.50Yellow cake, butter cream icing, and strawberry filling
- Raspberry Layer Cake$18.50Yellow cake, sweet raspberry filling, and butter cream topping
- Holiday Decorated Layer$18.95Specially decorated for each holiday. Yellow cake, butter cream icing, and strawberry or lemon filling
- Italian Rum Cake$18.95Rum soaked sponge layers with 1 layer vanilla custard and 1 layer of chocolate custard topped with our flavorful butter cream icing and sliced almonds
- All Chocolate Layer Cake$18.95All chocolate cake, chocolate fudge filled, and chocolate fudge iced. A chocolate lover's dream.
- Chocolate Iced Layer Cake$18.95Yellow cake, chocolate fudge icing and filling
- Oreo Cookie Cake$18.95Chocolate cake, oreo butter cream filling and topping
- "Nestle" Crunch Cake$18.95Chocolate cake, butter cream and crunch filling, chocolate and butter cream icing with a Nestle Crunch Bar topped for a treat
- Red Velvet Cake$18.50Butter Cream icing with chocolate ganache, the red velvet cake contains flour, sugar, cocoa, buttermilk, baking powder, salt, and vinegar. The filling is a rich cream cheese
- Dulce De Leche Cake$18.95Yellow cake, caramel filling, butter cream filling
- Supreme Bakery's cheesecake is made with the finest ingredients. Each bite is full of creamy rich taste of cream cheese
- Cheesecake by the slice - plain or chocolate$4.15
- Traditional 6" cream cheese cake$15.00
- 6" Fresh Strawberry Topped$17.00
- 6" Marble$17.00
- 6" Amaretto$17.00
- 10" - Plain10-12 Slices: $37.00
- 10" - Strawberry Topped$40.00
- 4" Fresh Fruit Tart$4.25Filled with bavarian cream and topped with seasonal fruits - strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, kiwi
- 9" Fresh Fruit Torte$20.00
- 9" Peach, Raspberry, or Blueberry Torte$20.00
- Baguette - Traditional French Bread$2.50Made with a poolish and only with unbleached unbromated flour, water, salt & yeast. All Natural Ingredients!
- Ciabatta - CiabattaItalian Flat Bread$3.25Means slipper in Italian because of the bread's shape. Same ingredients as the baguette with a little extra virgin olive oil. Enjoyed best as an appetizer dipped in olive oil, pesto, or with any type of Italian dish. Great for prosciutto sandwiches
- Foccacia$5.95$2.95Choose from onion, potato, or tomato. A meal in itself. Made with a biga (traditional Italian pre ferment). Flour, water, salt, yeast, olive oil, and parmesan cheese. Toppings include tomato-basil, potato rosemary, and carmelized onion
- Pan Bread (White)$2.50Not the Wonder bread you grew up with. This Pan White Bread is long fermented for maximum flavor and aroma. Contains flour, water, salt, yeast, butter, sugar, and milk powder. Great sandwich bread
- Sour Dough Multi-Grain$3.70Hearty bread that's high in fiber. Contains a blend of rye, whole wheat flour, white flour, salt, yeast, flax, sesame, rolled oats, and sunflower seeds. Made with a sour dough starter. Great eaten with a salad, or as a sandwich, or just enjoyed by itself
- Sour Dough Walnut Raisin$3.15Same as the Sour Dough Multi-Grain except it is great eaten with any type of cheese. When toasted it's a touch of sweetness
- Challah$4.502lb.: $9.003lb.: $13.955lb.: $24.95Our handmade twisted challah bread is perfect for your Sabbath. Perfect for french toast
- Pain Au Levain - Traditional Sour Dough Bread$3.15Following the traditional french bread making methods. Contains flour, rye, whole wheat flour, water, yeast, and salt
- Sour Dough Whole Wheat$2.50Made with a sour dough starter. Ingredients include flour, whole wheat flour, honey, yeast, and salt. Healthy whole grain bread. Great with tuna fish & sprouts
- Sour Dough Black Olive$3.75Traditional sour dough bread with Kalamata Olives and thyme added to the bread. Great with salads, as a dinner bread, or as a wholesome snack
- Semolina Bread$3.15Italian bread made with Durum Wheat and a sour dough and is great with pasta dishes and dipping in sauces
- Salt Free Tuscan$2.50Originally from the Tuscany area of Italy. This bread is a great combination with salty foods. Also good for people with salt restricted diet. Freezes well
- Cinnamon Raisin$3.15This bread has a wonderful cinnamon flavor with a touch of sweetness from the raisins. It's delicious lightly toasted and spread with unsalted butter or made as a French toast
- Rustic Italian$3.15Sunday dinner is not complete with the richness of this fine quality Italian bread perfect for dipping sauces and better for panino sandwiches
- Traditional Rye Bread$3.15Made with the richest rye flour and great sliced for your deli sandwiches
- Garlic Baguette Bread$2.95Traditional french bread with just the right touch of roasted garlic and oils
- Round Pumpernickel Bread$3.15Perfect for dips and healthy, too
- Brand New Cookie Collection$1.60
- When you are looking for more than just the ordinary cookie try our rich tasting tea time selection of large cookies. 10" Cookies $14.95, 12" Cookies $17.95. Special Design Cookies starting at $3.95 each. Great for party favors!!
- Large Almond Horns$2.95
- Chocolate Cigars$2.95
- Bullseye Cookies$2.95Raspberry or Apricot Fillled
- Raspberry Pretzels$2.50
- Elephant Ears$2.40Mini size available for $14.50/lb.
- Moon Cookies$2.40Also known as the black & white cookie
- Linzer tart$2.40
- Cookies with a portrai$2.50Bring in your photo
- Character Cookies$2.10
- For an afternoon pick-me up come into Supreme Bakery and choose from our selection of large cookies. Each cookie is $2
- Chocolate Chip
- Chocolate Chocolate Chip
- Oatmeal Raisin
- Peanut
- Maple Walnut
- Chocolate Sprinkled
- Rainbow Sprinkled
- Red Velvet, Chocolate Cake with M&M's, Oreo Cookies, Candy Bar, Chocolate Mousse, Vanilla Mousse, Tres Leche etc.
- Assorted colored cupcakes$1.25
- Chocolate frosted cupcakes$1.25
- Holiday decorated cupcakes$1.60high with sprinkles
- Lollipop cupcakes$1.60high with sprinkles
- Elmo, Cookie Monster or Big Bird Cupcakes$2.95
- Clown Specialty cupcake$2.95
- Basketball, Football, Soccer, & Baseball cupcake$2.95
- Specialty Cupcakes$1.60
- Jumbo Birthday Cupcakes$3.95
- Jumbo Red Velvet, Carrot, and Chocolate Ganache Cupcakes$3.95
- Mini Cupcakes$10.20
- We have a large selection of butter cookies. It includes lace cookies, tri-color rainbow cookies, raspberry filled, chocolate chip, chocolate dipped, sprinkled and more. Each tray is overwrapped with decorative paper. We can package and deliver your cookie order anywhere in the United States for and additional $15 fee. Local delivery is also available for an additional charge of $10 and a 3lb. tray minimum. Sugar free cookies are available in a one pound box for $14.50.
- Per pound of butter cookies$14.50Approx. 25 cookie
- 2 lb. tray$29.00
- 3 lb. tray$43.50
- 4 lb. tray$58.00
- 5 lb. tray$72.50
- 8" - $10.50, 10" - $17.50, 12" - $23. Mini Pies $3.95 each - Please order ahead
- Fresh Apple
- Apple Crumb
- Three Berry PieCherry, Blueberry, Strawberry Rhubarb
- Strawberry Rhubarb
- Cherry
- Peach
- Lemon
- Blueberry
- Lemon Meringue
- Pumpkin
- Pecan
- Mincemeat
- Sweet Potato
- Coconut Custard
- Sugar Free Apple or Cherry
- Plain$8.95
- Marble$8.95
- Nut$8.95
- All Chocolate$8.95
- Angel Food Cake$6.95
- Pumpkin$8.95
- Date & Nut$8.95
- Zucchini$8.95
- Cranberry Nut$8.95
- Five Grain$8.95
- Orange loaf$8.95
- Banana chocolate chip$8.95
- Lemon poppy$8.95
- Honey Loaf$8.95Plain or Nut
- Sponge Loaf$7.50Plain, Marble, or Nut
- $10.50 each - Can be cut up and put on trays for parties or bereavement
- Pineapple upside down cake
- Lemon ring
- Apple marble
- Pecan delite
- Fruit & Nut
- Marble
- Chocolate chip
- Orange crunch
- $10.25 per pound. These items can be plattered for a minimal charge
- Russian coffee cake
- Dresden stollen
- Mondelbrott
- Blueberry or Peach Cobbler (seasonal)
- Apple or Blueberry Crisp (seasonal)
- Poppy, Cheese, Almond, or Cinnamon Raisin Danish Strip
- Old World StrudelApple, Cheese, or Blueberry Cheese
- Bow Ties
- Cinnamon Sticks
- $8.95 each
- Chocolate
- Apple
- Fruit & Nut
- Cinnamon Raisin
- French Nut Cake
- Chocolate covered strawberriesStarting at: $2.50
- Napoleon$3.15
- Cannoli$2.60
- Large Cream Puffs$2.60Chocolate or Vanilla filled
- Mocha Log$3.15
- Tiramisu Slice$3.15
- Petit four$1.60
- Eclair$2.60
- Zeppole$2.60Cannoli filled or Custard filled
- Fancy Mousse Tart$3.95Chocolate, Vanilla, or Strawberry
- Flan Tart$2.60
- Key Lime Tart$3.95
- Guava Roll$2.60
- Sflogiatelle$1.35
- $1.35 each
- Mini cannoli
- Mini eclair
- Mini cream puff
- Mini sflogliatelle
- Mini fresh fruit tart
- Mini chocolate mousse tart
- Mini vanilla mousse tart
- Mini strawberry mousse tart
- Mini german chocolate tart
- Mini key lime tart
- $14.50 per pound
- Mini almond horns
- Scotch coffee cake
- Miniature danish
- Tri-color cookies
- Vanilla lace cookies
- Chocolate lace cookies
- Hazelnut biscotti
- Chocolate biscotti
- Mini elephant ears
- Chocolate rugglach
- Raspberry Almond rugglach
- Cinnamon raisin rugglach
- Pignoli cookiesspecial order only - $17.95 per lb.
- $2.60 each
- Strawberry shortcake
- Chocolate mousse
- German chocolate
- Carrot cake
- Cream Cheese
- Apple Squares
- Peach Cobbler (seasonal)
- Blueberry Crisp (seasonal)
- Sugar Free Birthday Cakes Available - please order ahead - Fresh whipped cream icing and sugar free fillings available
- 1lb. Sugar Free Boxed Butter Cookies$14.50
- Fruit Filled Sugar Free Puff Pastry$2.40Apple, Blueberry, Cherry
- 8" Sugar Free Apple or Cherry Pies$10.50
- West Orange residents know when it is breakfast time at Supreme Bakery. The aroma of breads, muffins, fresh donuts and pastries carries down Main Street, greeting passers-by on their way to work. Below are just a few of our Breakfast Specialties. Tomorrow, make Supreme Bakery your breakfast spot
- $1.15 each or $9.95 per dozen
- Old fashioned crumb
- Apple crumb
- Lemon
- Cinnamon raisin
- Cheese
- $9.95 per dozen
- Cinnamon coated old fashion cruellers$1.15
- Plain old fashion cruellers$1.15
- Cinnamon twisted cruellers$1.15
- Plain twisted cruellers$1.15
- Chocolate glazed donuts$1.15
- Plain glazed donuts$1.15
- Cinnamon coated jelly donuts$1.15
- Plain jelly donuts$1.15
- Powdered sugar jelly donuts$1.15
- Boston cream$1.15chocolate iced
- Powdered cream donuts$1.15
- Cinnamon Rolls or Apple Fritters$1.85
- $2.15 each or Half Size Danish $1.50 each
- Cheese
- Apricot
- Cinnamon raisin
- Prune
- Almond
- Nut ring
- Apple crumb
- Poppy seed
- Cherry
- Blueberry
- Pineapple
- Lemon
- Chocolate
- Large Size
- Oat bran$2.15
- Corn$2.15
- Blueberry$2.15
- Lemon poppy$2.15
- Zucchini$2.15
- Pumpkin$2.15
- Banana chocolate chip$2.15
- Cherry yogurt$2.15
- Carrot$2.15
- With Butter$2.35
- Apple Turnover$2.15
- Croissants$1.85With Butter: $2.25
- Tea Biscuit$2.05With Butter: $2.25
- Mini Turnovers$1.10
- Visit a friend for morning tea!
- Apple crumb$6.75
- Pecan$7.50
- Cheese$6.75
- Almond$6.75
- Coconut$6.75
- Four Fruit$6.75
- $1 each or Bakers Dozen (13) for $12. Buttered Bagel $1.50 or Cream Cheese Bagel $1.85. Half Size Bagel - $9 per dozen
- New York Style BagelsOnion, Pumpernickel, Salt, Sesame seed, Poppy seed, Cinnamon raisin, Marble, Everything bagel, Blueberry, Plain
- Fruit Smoothie: $3.95 Large Container To Go Hot Beverage: 10 Cups - $9.95
- Regular or Decaffeinated Fresh Brewed Coffee10oz.: $1.4716oz.: $1.85
- Iced Coffee$1.95
- Fresh Iced Tea$1.95
- Large Container of Coffee to go$9.95includes 10 cups, sugar, milk, cream
- Hot Tea$1.85
- Green Tea$1.85
- Hot Chocolate$1.85Large Size: $2.25
- Kaiser or Dinner rolls$0.75With Butter: $1.25
- Parkerhouse Rolls$0.80
- Portuguese or Italian rolls$0.75With Butter: $1.25
- Onion rolls$0.90With Butter: $1.25
- Challah rolls$1.00With Butter: $1.25
- Artisan rolls$0.80ciabatta, raisin, or pumpernickel