- Fifth N' Staregg, cheese & your choice of bacon, ham, or sausage on your choice of toast
- Green Eggs N' Hamscrambled eggs, spinach, ham, cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on whole grain
- The Dennisfried egg, sausage, cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo on rye
- served with buttered toast and jelly; sunny side up, over easy, over medium, over hard, over well, scrambled, basted, poached
- 1 Egg
- 2 Eggs
- 3 Eggs
- 4 Eggs (Square)
- 5 Eggs (Nickel)
- fresh fruit and whipped cream for an additional charge; ice cream and chocolate sauce for an additional charge
- Buttermilk Pancakes
- Blueberry Pancakes
- Pecan Pancakes
- Choc Chip Pancakes
- Belgian Waffle
- French Toasthand-dipped italian bread
- Paul's Corned Beef Hashtopped with two eggs any style
- Billy's Favoritetwo eggs, home fries, sausage gravy & buttermilk biscuits
- Paul's Sausage Gravyserved with buttermilk biscuits
- Early Risertwo eggs, home fries, toast & your choice of ham, bacon or sausage
- Juiceorange | cranberry | apple | grapefruit | tomato
- Soft Drinks
- Hot or Iced Tea
- Coffee
- Lemonade
- Milk
- Hand-Dipped Milk Shakes
- Floats
- Cerealfruit for an additional charge
- Old Fashioned Oatsblueberries and toasted pecans for an additional charge
- Crunchy GranolaServed with fresh fruit and banana bread. Yogurt for an additional charge
- "What's a Callahan?" No eggs! Simply the same ingredients served on top of home fries. Prepared with american cheese unless specified otherwise, served with buttered toast and jelly. Egg whites may be substituted for an additonal charge
- Paul's Special Omelet or Callahansix eggs, sausage, bacon, ham, onions, peppers, potatoes, tomatoes
- Greekspinach, onions, feta
- Milanogrilled chicken, onions, mushrooms, provolone
- Louiesausage, spinach, black beans, onions
- Westernham, peppers, onions
- The Josephham, potatoes, sausage gravy
- Chicken Charliegrilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, swiss "alpo" style
- Hash Housecorned beef hash n' swiss
- The Charliesausage n' cheese "alpo" style
- Spanishonions, peppers, mushrooms, stewed tomatoes
- Meat Lovergrilled chicken, ham, sausage, bacon
- Vegetablespinach, onions, peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes
- The Millerchili, spinach, mushrooms, peppers, onions, cheddar
- Santa Fegrilled chicken, provolone, black beans, spanish sauce
- Wisconsinprovolone, swiss, american, cheddar
- Build Your Own OmeletPick any three items: bacon, grilled chicken, corned beef hash, sausage, ham, chili, sausage gravy, onions, black beans, mushrooms, spinach, swiss, provolone, cheddar, pepper jack, feta. Additional Items for an additional charge
- Paul's Hash
- Ham
- Bacon
- Sausage
- Mac N' Cheese
- Fried Mac
- Home FriesOnions and Cheese for an additonal charge
- Joe FriesOnions and Cheese for an additonal charge
- Onion Rings
- Baked Beans
- French FriesCheese, Sausage Gravy, Chili, Bacon and Brown Gravy for an additional charge
- Tater TotsCheese, Sausage Gravy, Chili, Bacon and Brown Gravy for an additional charge
- Toast
- English Muffin
- Banana Bread
- Fresh Fruit
- Danish
- Coleslaw
- Cottage Cheese
- Applesauce
- Chicken Salad
- Tuna Salad
- Italian Wedding Soup
- Paul's Hearty Chili
- Soup of the Day
- Paul's House Saladhouse greens, sliced roma tomatoes, cucumbers, marinated onions, shaved parmesan, paul's house dressing
- Antipasto Saladhouse greens, genoa salami, capicolla, pepperoni, provolone, roma tomatoes, onions, croutons, banana peppers, shaved parmesan, paul's house dressing
- Fifth Avenue SaladHouse greens, roma tomatoes, spiced almonds, feta, maple-balsamic vinaigrette. Grilled Chicken and Grilled Salmon for an additional charge
- Chef Saladfresh greens topped with strips of turkey, ham, swiss & american, hard boiled eggs & tomatoes - your choice of dressing
- Chicken or Tuna Salad Platehouse-made chicken or tuna salad served with fresh fruit salad & freshly baked banana bread
- served with potato chips & pickle spear
- Brisket Meltbraised brisket, swiss, caramelized onions & a side of horseradish sauce on grilled rye
- Reubenhouse-braised corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss & 1000 island on grilled rye
- Wisconsin Grilled CheeseProvolone, swiss, cheddar & american on grilled italian. Bacon or Ham for an additional charge
- Enzio's Italian Meltgenoa salami, capicola, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, banana peppers & italian dressing on grilled italian
- Turkey Bacon Cheddar Meltturkey breast, smoked bacon, cheddar & honey mustard on grilled italian
- Black Bean Burgerblack bean and veggie patty, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles & roasted red pepper mayo on toasted bun
- Chicken or Tuna Saladmade in-house daily served on your choice of toast
- BLTSmoked bacon, tomatoes, lettuce & mayo on toasted italian. Egg for an additional charge
- Turkey Slawoven roasted turkey breast, swiss, coleslaw & honey mustard on grilled rye
- The Clubberhouse roasted turkey breast, deli ham, smoked bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on toasted italian
- Veggie Meltspinach, black beans, mushrooms, tomatoes, peppers, onions, provolone & red pepper mayo on grilled italian
- Tuna Melthouse-made tuna salad & swiss on grilled whole grain
- Our 6oz burgers are a proprietary blend of fresh ground short ribs & beef round with house seasonings. All burgers come with lettuce, tomatoes, & pickles served on grilled bun - mayo and onions on request. Substitute black bean burger or chicken breast on request
- Fifth Avenue HamburgerCheese and Smoked Bacon for an additonal charge
- Wonderburgersliced ham, smoked bacon, american
- Pantry Burgerdeli ham, provolone, bleu cheese
- Brunch Burgersmoked bacon, spinach, swiss, fried egg
- BBQ Burgerhouse-made bbq sauce, coleslaw, onion rings
- Popeye the Greekspinach, sautéed onions, feta
- Roman Burgergenoa salami, capicola, pepperoni, banana peppers, provolone, red sauce
- Chili Burger (Knife N' Fork)paul's famous chili, cheddar, sour cream
- Ohio Hot Mess (Knife N' Fork)open-faced with smoked bacon, deli ham, grilled onions, american, sausage gravy
- Patty Meltsautéed onions, swiss, 1000 island on grilled rye
- Gourmet Burgersmoked bacon, sautéed mushrooms, swiss
- Crazy Burger (Crazy Good)smoked bacon, mac n' cheese, pepper jack
- Chicken Italianomarinated grilled chicken, sautéed onions, mushrooms, peppers, provolone
- Grilled Chicken Clubmarinated chicken breast, smoked bacon, swiss, honey mustard
- Chicken Briegrilled chicken breast, caramelized onions, brie, apricot marmalade
- Mama Panzera's Lasagnalayers of pasta, seasoned ground chuck, ricotta, spinach, parmesan, herbs & spices, red sauce, provolone, and romano
- Pasta N' MeatballLinguine with traditional red sauce or marinara sauce. Additional Meatball (Ea) for an additonal charge
- Meatball Slidersmeatballs served on two rosemary-focaccia rolls with provolone & red sauce on the side
- Chicken or Veal Parmesancrispy filet of chicken or crispy veal patty with provolone, paul's famous red sauce & a side of pasta
- Chicken or Veal Parmesan Sandwichcrispy filet of chicken or crispy veal patty, provolone & red sauce served on bun
- House-Baked Piesask your server for selection
- Pie Ala Mode
- Paul's Bread Pudding