- Soft Ice Cream-our Own Special Recipe - Vanilla - Chocolate - Twist. We Now Have Flavor-burst Flavors!!!
- Small Cone/dish$2.40
- Medium Cone/dish$2.90
- Large Cone/dish$3.15
- Waffle Cone$3.15
- Junior Sundae$2.90
- Regular Sundae$3.50
- Xtra-large Sundae$4.00
- Banana Split$4.50
- Chocolate Dip$0.50
- Dry Toppings$0.50
- Soda Float$3.00
- Shakes$3.25
- Malt$3.50
- Creamsicle Shake$4.00
- Vanilla Or Chocolate Sandwich$1.70
- Old Tyme Sundae$2.75
- Fudge Brownie Sundae$4.00
- Variety Pack - 6 Assorted Cups$7.99
- 6 Pack Sandwiches$5.99vanilla or chocolate
- 6 Pack$6.99variety of sandwiches
- 6 Pack$6.99chocolate chip sandwiches
- Chocolate Chip Sandwich$1.85
- Fat Free$2.65no sugar added cup
- Slice Of Cake$3.00
- Smaller Cakes Add An Additional $2.00. Larger Cakes Add An Additional $3.00. An Edible Image Made From Your Photo Add $6.00
- Dessert CakeServes 5: $10.99
- 7 Inch Round CakeServes 9: $15.99
- 8 Inch Round CakeServes 12: $17.99
- 9 Inch Round CakeServes 15: $20.99
- Small Sheet CakeServes 20: $26.99
- 12 Inch Round CakeServes 25: $32.99
- Large Sheet CakeServes 30: $39.99
- Heart Shaped CakeServes 15: $19.99
- Fudge BrownieServes 12: $19.99all chocolate ice cream with walnuts, crunch, and fudge inside, covered with chocolate ice cream and topped with more crunch, fudge, & walnuts. its a keeper!
- Strawberry ShortcakeServes 12: $19.99all vanilla ice cream with strawberries & vanilla crunch inside and topped with marzipan strawberries. fabulous!
- Cookies & CreamServes 12: $19.99all vanilla ice cream with cookies & fudge inside then covered with creamy frosting and sprinkled with even more cookies then drizzled with chocolate. delightful
- Coffee SupremeServes 12: $19.99coffee & vanilla ice cream with fudge & crunch inside, topped with a layer of fudge & garnished with a maraschino cherry, delicious!
- Bittersweet EcstasyServes 12: $19.99vanilla & chocolate ice cream with bittersweet fudge & crunch inside. and drizzled all over the top - lots more fudge! its a favorite!
- Peanut Butter CupServes 12: $19.99all chocolate ice cream with double layers of peanut butter, peanuts, and chocolate drizzle. divided with a layer of chocolate crunch then topped with caramel and more peanuts and chocolate drizzle. unbelievable!
- Fish
- Train
- Dinosaur
- Dog
- Cat
- Race Car
- Rocking Horse
- Golf Bag
- Football Player
- Fire Engine
- Clown
- Lion
- Happy Birthday(a real favorite), and more! most are special order items.
- Each Holiday, Season, And Special Occasion Brings A New Parade Of Shapes, Characters, And Designs To Mr. Peepers Ice Cream.
- Hearts
- Leprechauns
- Bunnies And Eggs
- Mothers And Fathers Day
- Communions
- Confirmations
- Graduation
- Forth Of July
- Pumpkins
- Turkeys
- Santas
- Christmas Trees
- Snowmen
- Candy Canes
- Candles
- Greeting Cards,
- Paper Party Supplies