< See More Results
 
A
B
Miles     Kilometers
  Reset

Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant

4.5 of 5 stars 5 Reviews

374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 561-6262
 
 

Business Details

Categories

(Edit)
Pizza Restaurants, Restaurants

Hours of Operation

(Edit)
  • Mon-Sat
  • Open Sundays

Products & Services

(Edit)
  • Anchovies
  • Antipasti
  • Artichoke Hearts
  • Bacon
  • Black Olives
  • More
  • Broccoli
  • Brooklyn Pizza
  • Buffalo Chicken
  • Buffalo Shrimp
  • Calamata Olives
  • Eggplant
  • Extra Cheese
  • Fried OR Grilled Chicken
  • Grandma'S Pizza
  • Grilled Chicken Cheesesteak
  • Italian Cheesesteak - W Mozzarella, Peppers, Onions & Marinara Sauce
  • Large
  • Large (16")
  • Mama Theresa's Giambotta - Peppers, Onions, Meatballs, Sausage and Pepperoni.
  • ME
  • Meatballs
  • Medium
  • Medium (14")
  • MUSHROOM CHEESESTEAK
  • Neopolitan Brick Oven Pizza
  • Onions
  • Pepper & Onion Cheesesteak
  • Pepperoni
  • Peppers
  • Philly Cheesesteak
  • Philly Cheesesteaks
  • Pizza Toppings
  • Roasted Red Peppers
  • Sausage
  • Sicilian
  • Sicilian Cheesesteak - With Broccoli Rabe, Provolone and Onions
  • Spinach
  • Zuchini
  • Less

Additional Information

  • Mama Theresa's Neopolitan Pizza Is Made With Mama Theresa's Own Handmade Fresh Mozzarella, Vine Ripened Tomatoes Make Our Sauce the One You Prefer, Aged Imported Romano Cheese Brings A Richness You Ha... More Mama Theresa's Neopolitan Pizza Is Made With Mama Theresa's Own Handmade Fresh Mozzarella, Vine Ripened Tomatoes Make Our Sauce the One You Prefer, Aged Imported Romano Cheese Brings A Richness You Have Come To Expect From Everything You Order From Mama Theresa's and Topped Off With the Finest of Italy's Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Will Make Every Bite You Take of Mama Theresa's Neopolitan Pizza Transport You To Sunny Naples., This Is the Pizza the Whole Country Tries To Imitate., Mama Theresa's Roots Are in Brooklyn and No One Knows Brooklyn Pizza Better Than Mama Theresa's., back in the 1940'S, Before There Was A Pizza Shop On Each Corner in Brooklyn, Neopolitan Grandmas Looked for A Way To Feed Their Families Without Breaking the Family Budget. Bringing To Life the Traditions of Naples, They Took To Making A Simple Yet Delicious Pizza in Square Pans That Could Fit in A Traditional Home Oven and Feed Their Entire Family. It Became A Family Favorite Adorned With Olive Oil, Garlic, Basil, Romano Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella That Can Melt in You Mouth and the Love That Only Grandma Can Add. Here Is Mama Theresa's Version for Your Family To Try and Enjoy!, Personal, Large, Sicilian and Grandma's, onions, mama T'S Specialty Pizza, A Taste of Italy - Artichoke Hearts, Roasted Red Peppers, Black Olives and Fontina Cheese., Eggplant Napolean - Mama Theresa's Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Fire Red Roasted Peppers and Our Own Balsamic Vinegar Glaze., Buffalo Shrimp - Large Breaded and Fried Shrimp Tossed in Mama Theresa's Spicy Buffalo Sauce and Topped With BLEU Cheese Dressing., Pizza Margarita - Mama Theresa's Handmade Fresh Mozzarella, Roma Tomatoes, Imported Romano Cheese, Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Roasted Garlic., Greek Goddess - Marinated Grilled Chicken, Feta Cheese, Calamata Olives, Red Onions, Pepperoncini W Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Roasted Garlic., Home On the Range - Your Choice of Grilled OR Fried Chicken Breast With Creamy Ranch Dressing, Topped With Crispy Bacon., Pizza Insalate - Romaine Lettuce, Black Olives, Fresh Roma Tomatoes, Red Onions, Fire Roasted Red Peppers With Balsamic Dressing, The Dominuche - Mama Theresa's Fresh Mozzarella, Ricotta, Prosciutto, Imported Romano Cheese, Topped With Tomato Sauce, Grilled Chicken- Sliced Plump Chicken Breasts Marinated and Served With Mama Theresa's Pesto Sauce., White Pizza - Ricotta, Imported Regiano Parmigian, Romano Cheese, Mozzarella and Fresh Garlic., White Pizza Plus - Choose One From the Following: Grilled Chicken, Broccoli, Spinach OR Grilled Vegetables., Pizzeria & Italian Eatery, Made From USDA Choice Sirloin. Add Mushrooms OR Extra Cheese Sauce ( .50). Add Mozzarella (, Hot Antipasti - Baled Clams, Eggplant Rollatini, Stuffed Mushrooms, Pizza Rustica Balls and Fried Mozzarella., Cold Antipasti - Prosciutto, Salami, Cappicola, Imported Provolone, Mozzarella, Mixed Olives, Roasted Peppers Over A Bed of Mixed Greens, Baked Clams Organata - Littleneck Clams, Topped With Mama Theresa's Seasoned Bread Crumbs. Extra Virgin Olive Oil., Steamed Mussells (12) Choose From Spice Marinara Sauce OR White Wine and Garlic With Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Stuffed Mushrooms - Stuffed With Mushrooms, Peppers, Bread Crumbs and Romano Cheese, Rice Balls - A Mixture of Rice, Mozzarella, Romano Cheese, Imported Spices Blended Then Shaped As A ConLess
 

Are You the Business Owner?

Claim your free business listing on Superpages.com and add important information about your business online. The more reviews and additional information you provide about your business, the easier it will be for customers to find you online.

  • Manage your reviews and ratings
  • Create coupons
  • Connect with customers
Write a Review   |   My Ratings & Reviews   |   User Reviews   |   Blogs

User Reviews

The person icon Empolyee Image indicates that the reviewer is an employee of SuperMedia LLC. SuperMedia operates and sells advertising on Superpages.com. The views expressed in reviews are the opinion of each respective reviewer and do not necessarilly reflect the view of SuperMedia.
5 of 5 stars
Feb 15, 2012
by Guest68229
business
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant 374 Windsor Hwy,
New Windsor, NY 12553
USA
Mama Theresa's food is made with the very finest, fresh daily ingredients! They are the best Italian restaurant in the country! The pastries, the pizza, the meals are just fabulous in quality, freshness, and flavor! They are a 10+. There deliver... (More)
Was this Review helpful to you?   Yes No   
5 of 5 stars
Sep 14, 2011
by anonymous
business
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant 374 Windsor Hwy,
New Windsor, NY 12553
USA
This pizza is the closest thing to NYC pizza in Orange County. Nice thin crust with good sauce. A little more cheese never hurts.
Was this Review helpful to you?   Yes 1 No 0   
3 of 5 stars
Oct 7, 2009
by Guest31666
business
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant 374 Windsor Hwy,
New Windsor, NY 12553
USA
pizza is good. food is alright. very small dining room. service is not what it used to be.
Was this Review helpful to you?   Yes 1 No 0   
5 of 5 stars
Jul 19, 2009
by Guest25517
business
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant 374 Windsor Hwy,
New Windsor, NY 12553
USA
I love this hidden little Italian gem. Whether you're just grabbing a slice of pizza or ordering the lemon chicken, the food here is amazing! It can take a while just to get a table...and for the food to come, but it is well worth the wait. Just ask... (More)
Was this Review helpful to you?   Yes 1 No 0   
5 of 5 stars
Mar 28, 2009
by Guest29891
business
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant 374 Windsor Hwy,
New Windsor, NY 12553
USA
Their Grandma's pizza is fantastic for takeout. The restaurant in back is a little cramped, but that's because it's usually packed. We had to wait about 10 miutes for our table, and the manager came over with some snacks for us to try while we wai... (More)
Was this Review helpful to you?   Yes 2 No 0   

Blogs

1-5 of 5 Results

 
 
Browse to locate your photos. All photos are subject
to review and take at least 24 hours to appear on the site.

JPEG or GIF only, no larger than 5MB
Enter a title for your photo and upload.

By uploading a photo you are agreeing to our Photo Guidelines
 
Data provided by one or more of the following: SuperMedia, Acxiom, Infogroup
User Generated Content Guidelines
    Edit this Business Info - Publishing Guidelines
  • User provided updates will not over-write updates provided by the business owner.
  • Superpages.com's editorial department will review the updates, but does not validate the updates with the business.
  • Information provided will be screened and must meet the Content Guidelines before it is published on Superpages.com.
  • Superpages.com reserves the right to remove any content that does not conform to policy.
  • By submitting information, you are granting Superpages.com permission to publish the information you provided.
  • Most submissions take at least 24 hours and may take up to a week to appear online.
    Photos - Publishing Guidelines
  • For photos to publish, the user has to be a registered Superpages.com user.
  • The user will receive an email from Superpages.com asking them to click the link verifying that the photo can be published on Superpages.com.
  • All photos will be edited by Superpages.com staff.
  • The photos must meet the Superpages.com Photo Guidelines.
    • The Content was created by me or by my employees or by a third party who has given me written permission to use the Content in the manner contemplated by the Application.
    • If the Content includes a person or persons, I have obtained from each person in the photo the unrestricted right to use the photo.
    • I have the unrestricted right and authority to use the Content in any media and in any advertising published under the Application in the way it is used.
  • Superpages.com reserves the right to remove any content that does not conform to policy.
  • By submitting information, you are granting Superpages.com permission to publish the information you provided.
  • Most submissions take at least 24 hours and may take up to a week to appear online
    Business Blogs - Publishing Guidelines
  • For Business Blogs to publish, the user has to be a registered Superpages.com user.
  • The user will receive an email from Superpages.com asking them to click the link verifying that the blog can be published on Superpages.com.
  • Blogs will be edited by Superpages.com staff.
  • The Blogs must meet the Superpages.com Content Guidelines.
  • Superpages.com reserves the right to remove any content that does not conform to policy.
  • By submitting information, you are granting Superpages.com permission to publish the information you provided.
  • Most submissions take at least 24 hours and may take up to a week to appear online.
    Abuse Policy
  • Content that is not acceptable can be reported through our Report Abuse link. Superpages.com staff will review all reports and remove those that violate policy.
  • The following may be considered abusive and lead to the removal of content:
    • Profane, obscene, abusive, offensive, objectionable, unintelligible language.
    • Adult material, including graphic images, written images, URLs, or links.
    • Negative comments about individual employees, including names.
    • References to another company, whether by name, domain name, trademarks or service marks.
    • Malicious intent