The Best Pizza in NYC Comes to Freehold. New Yorkers are tough critics especially when it comes to their pizza. So when Krispy Pizza won the "Battle of the Borough" (featuring pizza from all 5 boroughs & Long Island ) at the New York Pizza Expo 2005, a clear message was sent. Krispy Pizza is the best. Brothers Vinny, Tony Freddy & Al grew up in this family run business started by their dad over 40 years ago in Dyker Heights Brooklyn, where Krispy Pizzeria is legendary. Topping the list of 15 varieties of pizza is their specialty pie, Grandma's Pizza, a thin crust Sicilian with fresh mozzarella,fresh tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil & just the right touch of basil.